Moglet wrote:
NYAF, how does the Ultimat score over the Fletcher kit?
Hi Moglet,
I have used both and to be honest I very much a Keencut fan, however the Fletcher-Terry is more solid in terms of lack of movement when inserting the blade at the start of cut. It is actually a lot more difficult to produce a hooked cut on the Fletcher-Terry than on the Keencut Ultimat. I don't know if there is any difference between the Ultimat and the Ultimat gold in this regard.
Another difference between the Fletcher-Terry and the Ultimat is if you use the slideway bar for marking out for multi-aperture mounts. On the Fletcher-Terry there is no difference between where you rule you pencil line and where the blade cuts, but on the Ultimat there is a difference which is a disadvantage.
In spite of all that I still prefer the Ultimat, because:
You don't have to mess around cleaning those little wheels which the cutting head runs on.
The start of cut stop finger is mounted on the cutting head so you don't have to keep repositioning the start of cut stop as you cut each side of the mount unless the mount margin width is different.
The mount margin guide can be removed or replaced in seconds, which helps when cutting multi-aperture mounts.
The rear extension arm can be removed or replaced in seconds.
The handle with which you insert the blade is much more comfortable in use.
However, having said all that, if I was buying another mountcutter at this time I would be deciding whether to chose a Keencut Ultimat Gold or a C&H Vantage which is also a fantastic mountcutter and has a very substantial looking phospher bronze bearing on which the cutting head runs. Having owned the previous C&H model, I can assure you it's the business for accuracy and blade control.
If I had to chose between the Fletcher-Terry and the C&H Vantage - It would be the C&H - As I said I have used both.
The very slight flexibility of the plastic bearings on which the Ultimat cutting head runs is it's only negative aspect, which I can happily live with. In all other aspects the Ultimat is in my opinion the best mountcutter. It's comfortable to use, easy for maintenance and the back-up from Keencut is excellent.